Nonlinear response of community stability to ambient climate determines response direction of community stability to warming and grazing

The impacts of human-driven environmental changes on the stability of natural grasslands have been assessed by comparing differences between manipulative warming and grazing plots and reference plots. However, little is known about whether or how ambient climate regulates the effects of manipulative treatments. A 36-year observational dataset shows that there is a nonlinear response of community stability to ambient climate. Manipulative warming and grazing decrease community stability with experiment duration through an increase in legume coverage and/or decrease in species asynchrony, due to exceeding the threshold of background annual mean air temperature with decreasing background annual mean air temperature through time during the 10-year experiment period. Moreover, the temperature sensitivity of community stability is more sensitive under the ambient treatment than under the manipulative treatments. Therefore, our study emphasizes the importance of the context dependency of the response of community stability to human-driven environmental changes.